Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Maxine DeSeta testifies on licensing and City Bike profits

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 5:56:57 · 2 min 5 sec

Maxine DeSeta calls for licensing and registration of all micromobility vehicles, criticizes City Bike's profits and donations to Transportation Alternatives, and says the proposals are irrelevant without Priscilla's Law.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Hello?

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Okay.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Maxine DeSeta, native New Yorker.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

All micro-mobility vehicles, especially lift-on city bikes, must be licensed and registered.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Pedestrians must not be afraid of crossing the street.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Your 20 proposals are irrelevant in terms of safety for the pedestrian and riders.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

If you choose not to support Priscilla's law, you are endorsing by default what the policy executive of Lyft, City Bike's parent company, has said.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Wider helmet laws and registration mandates.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

could have a devastating effect on City Bike's business model.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

DOT's own bike share data in 2025 showed a net profit of $24.6 million with $4.2 million revenue to the city.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

This means only 15% of their net profit was given back to the city that gives them taxpayer-funded curb space.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Lyft-owned City Bike donates to transportation alternatives a multi-million dollar non-profit to the tune of over $100,000 yearly.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

TransAlt's mission?

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

To reclaim New York City from cars, transforming our streets into safe, sustainable, blah, blah, blah, to walk and bike.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

There is no mention of reclaiming New York City from nonprofit car shares or Ubers that are causing midtown congestion.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Current TOT's Transportation Streets Master Plan funding is nearly $39.5 million

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

in the fiscal year 2020-27 to redesign our streets with bike lanes that are useless for regular bikers.

Member of the Public - Maxine DeSeta

Thank you.

Harvey D. Epstein

Next.