Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Jean Ryan testifies on locked grocery gate and CCHR delay

New York City Council · Oct 16, 2026 · starts 2:27:51 · 2 min 43 sec

Jean Ryan, president of Disabled in Action, says a Bay Ridge grocery store locked a gate during business hours, blocking wheelchair and walker users. She says CCHR took her case almost four years ago but nothing has legally stopped the store, and her emails to the commissioner have gone unanswered.

Shahana K. Hanif

Thank you, Monique.

Shahana K. Hanif

We're moving on to Jean Ryan.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Hi, I'm Jean Ryan, wheelchair user and president of Disabled in Action in Metropolitan New York.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Are you going to the grocery store today after work?

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

I bet you know that you can go right in and you won't be locked out by a gate.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

25 and 30 years ago, that used to be a common occurrence for wheelchair users, that we'd be locked out and upright people could get into grocery stores with no problem.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Then the NYC Human Rights Commission helped us get our civil rights and have access to grocery stores without the gates being locked.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Now it's happening again in some stores, and we can forget about getting any help from the commission.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Four years ago, next month, so it's like in two weeks, it's going to be four years, a grocery store in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn Harvest Market, started locking a gate during business hours.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

That kept out wheelchair and walker users, people who use strollers, and people with their own large shopping carts.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Upright people could walk right in.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Sometimes I was able to gain access by waiting outside and asking a stranger to ask them to come out and unlock the gate.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

But walking people didn't have to do that.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

They could walk right in.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

I talked with the manager and he didn't

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

I complained to the Human Rights Commission, and they took my case.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

But in almost four years, nothing has happened on their end to legally stop Brooklyn Harvest Market.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Now the gate is unlocked, but there is nothing preventing them from locking the gate whenever they want.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

And recently, another grocery store in Bay Ridge had a locked gate.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

For months, my case has not been assigned to anyone, and my emails to the commissioner have gone unanswered.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

I emailed her six weeks ago.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

go on September 4th and have not gotten an answer.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

I asked Moped to intervene and nothing changed.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

They did try.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Why is nothing happening?

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Why is this case dragging on for four years?

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

Everyone has the right to shop in a grocery store.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

The Human Rights Commission has become irrelevant to most people with disabilities.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

They aren't there for us to protect our rights.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

We don't even think of them as a resource.

Member of the Public - Jean Ryan

That needs to change.