Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Menin asks about Anthropic evaluators and third-party validation

New York City Council · Oct 16, 2026 · starts 0:57:49 · 1 min 46 sec

Menin notes Anthropic's statement about independent evaluators and Musk's reply that SpaceX would probably do the same, asking whether SpaceX agrees to third-party validators with employee-level access; Castillo-Madrid cites White House accord commitments to independent external auditors and evaluators.

Julie Menin

Thank you.

Julie Menin

Okay.

Julie Menin

Last night, Anthropic issued a statement that they are committed to having evaluators assess their safety practices and giving employee-like access to a team from

Julie Menin

Model Evaluation and Threat Research Not-for-Profit Evaluation Group.

Julie Menin

Elon Musk then replied that SpaceX would, quote, probably do the same, end quote.

Julie Menin

Is that the position of the company?

Member of the Public - Gabriela Castillo Madrid

As part of the White House accord, ongoing collaboration was part of it.

Member of the Public - Gabriela Castillo Madrid

And regular meetings among companies to establish standards and best practices are very important.

Member of the Public - Gabriela Castillo Madrid

This is an evolving technology and safety is at the forefront of everything we do.

Member of the Public - Gabriela Castillo Madrid

So we want to make sure that we're doing everything we can to keep our system safe.

Julie Menin

So is that a yes or a no that you would have agreed to this kind of third party validation?

Member of the Public - Gabriela Castillo Madrid

Independent external evaluation was also part of the agreements and just getting partnerships with independent external auditors and evaluators to assess model capabilities, controls and safeguards.

Julie Menin

So do you agree that for SpaceX AI, or really for any AI company, when they commit to third-party validators, they must be independent,

Julie Menin

and that the company needs to give those validators high-level employee-level access, along with all the appropriate and necessary information so they can truly do the work to validate?

Member of the Public - Gabriela Castillo Madrid

Yeah, partnership with independent external auditors and evaluators to assess safety is part of what we already have agreed on.