Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Freena challenges officials on political inaction over EMS pay

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:54:17 · 2 min 12 sec

Andrew Freena, a former EMT and current PA, says the FDNY chief says life-threatening jobs are not held, but paramedics across all boroughs arrive under 10 minutes only 26% of the time. He says pay parity would cost a small fraction of the city budget and asks why the issue remains unsolved.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

My name is Andrew Freena.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

I'm a former EMT, current PA.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Not to beat a dead horse about the response times, you've heard a lot of harrowing metrics, but the FDNY commissioner, or not the commissioner, the chief, I think he said something correct that they don't hold life-threatening jobs.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

But if you look at the statistics,

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

The percentage of time across all five boroughs where the paramedics arrive under 10 minutes is 26% as of the last month, which is pretty awful.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

So you must be holding jobs.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Regardless, it's nice to hear this discussion here, how everyone's recognizing that the pay is the problem and that it needs to be solved.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

But it just it confuses me why the issue is not solved.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

I see it as relatively simple, right?

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

This really isn't a partisan issue, a political issue.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Whether you're a Democrat or Republican, a socialist, whatever, if we live in the city and our families live here, we want the ambulance to show up fast.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

I think it's what, like two, three, maybe $400 million to achieve parity.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Yes, that's a lot of money, but out of $112 billion budget, it's not that much.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

When you see that other agencies receive federal funds or state funds, that's another alternative.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

So

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

plus the insurance billing.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

There's a lot of solutions here.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

And it makes me start to wonder, you know, I don't mean to say this offensively, but like, do you have your own private ambulance services or do you not live in the city?

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Because aren't you worried about yourselves?

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Like, I just feel like that's, you know, this is also an issue that you can be a little selfish about.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

But it frustrates me as someone who's not a politician, not a union leader.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Like, what do I do?

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

I call my office.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

I live in Long Island City.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Thankfully, I wasn't on the ground, you know, with a compound fracture, but they don't care.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Julie Wan doesn't care, right?

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

We call these politicians and they don't want to do much.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

And there's a lot of trying to blame the fire department.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

And then they try to blame you guys.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

And people just keep pointing the finger.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

So it becomes very frustrating as a constituent.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

And I just hope we can actually, you know, we're talking about it.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

That's great.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

But I hope we come to a solution now.

Member of the Public - Andrew Freena

Thank you.