Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Epstein asks for public-facing ambulance tracking and callback info

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 1:42:48 · 2 min 43 sec

Council Member Harvey Epstein asks whether ambulances are GPS-tracked and whether any of that information is public-facing. Miano says ambulances are tracked internally to dispatch the closest unit, but there is no public interface and no way for callers to get updated ETA information.

Harvey D. Epstein

Thank you, Chair.

Harvey D. Epstein

Thank you for all being here.

Harvey D. Epstein

So it sounds like there's consensus that we need to pay our EMSs more.

Harvey D. Epstein

It sounds like there's some opportunity to be working on that in the, either this year and then through negotiations or next year in the budget.

Harvey D. Epstein

But I think we're trying to look at what's happening, the public-facing aspect of it, and we're trying to ensure the public has good, accurate information so they can

Harvey D. Epstein

be able to make informed choices about waiting a half hour or getting into a cab or making other choices about maybe not the priority emergencies.

Harvey D. Epstein

Like what system, you know, like are there all the EMS vehicles, are they GPS tracked?

Paul Miano

Yes.

Harvey D. Epstein

So there's the current system to monitor where those vehicles are and where they're going, right?

Paul Miano

Yes, and that's how we determine which, aside from acuity, whether it needs an ALS or a BLS ambulance, that's how we determine which ambulance is closest to respond to that call.

Harvey D. Epstein

And none of that is publicly facing, right?

Harvey D. Epstein

None of that information is publicly facing.

Paul Miano

Meaning that someone can log in and see where ambulances are.

Harvey D. Epstein

Yeah, there's ambulances on the way.

Harvey D. Epstein

There's no way to know if that's actually true, right?

Paul Miano

No, currently no.

Harvey D. Epstein

There's no way for someone to call 911 back again to be able to say, hey, how soon is an ambulance coming?

Harvey D. Epstein

There's no way to do that, right?

Paul Miano

No.

Harvey D. Epstein

So you understand the concern that people have that, you know, my kid broke his leg and we're waiting at the playground for the ambulance to come.

Harvey D. Epstein

And if it's going to be an hour, I may make a different choice than sitting there for an hour with my kid who's in pain with a broken leg, right?

Harvey D. Epstein

I think we're all trying to solve this problem.

Paul Miano

I do.

Paul Miano

I appreciate everything that you're saying, and I think we appreciate what the bill is intended to do.

Paul Miano

But, you know, in this situation, like the speaker's constituent who called, right, we had ambulances responding.

Paul Miano

So we don't want, but a higher acuity call came in and they needed to be redirected.

Paul Miano

So we don't want to.

Paul Miano

Tell somebody.

Harvey D. Epstein

You can tell them, hey, you know what?

Harvey D. Epstein

We had an ambulance.

Harvey D. Epstein

They were redirected.

Harvey D. Epstein

We're letting you know this ambulance is redirected, and we're looking for another ambulance to send to you.

Harvey D. Epstein

So that, like, information, I know people...

Harvey D. Epstein

We're busy, but there's maybe some automation that can help in that.

Harvey D. Epstein

It's like we all have the technologies out there that we can do more publicly facing technology to help people with this information.

John Esposito

We agree and we will take a look at that.

John Esposito

We know that when they have the information that it might not be coming soon, that they might take alternate action.

Harvey D. Epstein

I appreciate that.

Harvey D. Epstein

And that saves the system in sending an hour later a vehicle that there's no one there waiting for anymore.