Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Restler criticizes prior DOP mismanagement and asks about restoring eliminated programs

New York City Council · Oct 26, 2026 · starts 0:38:22 · 3 min 2 sec

Council Member Restler says DOP was badly mismanaged under the previous administration and asks how DOP will restore programs that were cut, including Impact, Next Steps, Arches, AIM, and ICM. Goodwin says DOP may not bring back old programs but will develop new ones and is working with community organizations.

Sharon Goodwin

and we can get a better read and evaluation about our work.

Sharon Goodwin

Thank you.

Selvena N. Brooks-Powers

Councilmember, if you have more questions, I can bring you up after Councilmember.

Selvena N. Brooks-Powers

Thank you very much.

Selvena N. Brooks-Powers

Thanks.

Lincoln Restler

Thanks so much, Chair Brooke Powers, and it's great to be with you here at this committee and great to be with the leadership of the Department of Probation.

Lincoln Restler

Over the last four years, I received many, many dozens of complaints.

Lincoln Restler

Lots were anonymous of cronyism, corruption, incompetence at the Department of Probation.

Lincoln Restler

I will tell you of all of the agencies that I think were badly mismanaged during the previous administration, none more so than the Department of Probation.

Lincoln Restler

And so the scale of the turnaround that you are charged with is greater than any other commissioner in city government.

Lincoln Restler

And it's really tragic to me what the previous administration did because over your 40-year career, the Department of Probation had been a model of reform and innovation in city government.

Lincoln Restler

From the Bloomberg to the de Blasio administrations, we had great leaders who were doing really compelling and innovative things.

Lincoln Restler

And that all came to a really harsh stop in recent years.

Lincoln Restler

And so I'm heartened by your testimony today.

Lincoln Restler

I'm impressed by your plan to be fully staffed up at the end of next year.

Lincoln Restler

You know, it takes– when somebody hollows out an agency, when somebody–

Lincoln Restler

encourages, when somebody, I think, does such a poor job of leading an agency and people leave en masse and programs are eliminated, it takes time to build it back up.

Lincoln Restler

It doesn't happen in a day.

Lincoln Restler

I really want to focus my questions today around some of the programs that Commissioner Holmes eliminated and get an understanding of where they are and how you're repairing and restoring.

Lincoln Restler

I'm particularly concerned about youth incarceration.

Lincoln Restler

During the Adams administration, we went from about 150 kids in our juvenile detention facilities to well over 370.

Lincoln Restler

That number more than doubled.

Lincoln Restler

And part of the problem is that the Department of Probation was nowhere to be found and was not a partner.

Lincoln Restler

We heard from leaders across city government that they could no longer rely on DOP.

Lincoln Restler

And so we're keen to see how DOP is now stepping up to help solve these problems.

Lincoln Restler

Under the past administration, there were over $5 million in cuts to evidence-based programs that serve at-risk young adults, cuts of $700,000 to the impact program, $2.6 million to next steps, $1.6 million to arches,

Lincoln Restler

and DOP stopped making referrals to the AIM program, the Advocate Intervene Mentor Program.

Lincoln Restler

The Intensive Community Monitor Program, ICM, was reportedly hollowed out, and probation officers were joining ARCHES meetings, which goes against every best practice that I've ever come across.