Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Laura Spielman (equine specialist) testifies on horse biology and rescue experience

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 3:57:45 · 2 min 6 sec

Laura Spielman, founder of the Coalition for Responsible Carriage Horse Retirement and certified equine specialist, testifies about horse biology making them unsuitable for city work and her experience successfully placing 160 horses in rescue operations.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Firstly, to the Mahajan family, I'm so very sorry for your loss.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

My name is Laura Spielman.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I'm a founder of the Coalition for Responsible Carriage Horse Retirement, and I'm here to ask you to vote yes on Romacha's law.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I'm here as a New Yorker.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I was born and raised here.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Both sides of my family have lived here since the 1800s.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

My great-grandfather served as mounted PD in the park in the 20s.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Mounted police serve a vital public function.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Horse-drawn carriages do not.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I'm a certified equine specialist for two international organizations working with humans and horses.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I serve on both the Humane Society and ASPCA's large animal response teams.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I built and currently run an equine program for the Department of Defense to work with the Navy, the Marines, and Wounded Warriors.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I work with the VA, the prison system, law enforcement, children with developmental disabilities, and the general public.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

In the last five years, I've worked with over 200 people and 20 or so horses in my program, and I hold a perfect safety record because I put safety first.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

That means the safety of humans and the horses.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I know that the retirement plan is a central concern here, and it can be done.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I've done it before.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I've worked on a large-scale rescue effort involving over 160 horses, everyone evaluated, treated, and placed.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

I know from direct experience that a coordinated retirement of this very size can be done.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

And here's the science why they should be retired.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

A horse sees nearly 340 degrees around its body, but it has blind spots directly in front and behind.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

So traffic.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Agreed is an unseen threat.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Its eyes adjust to light far slower than ours, so a shift from sun to shadow or a camera flash causes real disorientation, not disobedience.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

Their hearing can trigger a full flight response from a siren or a backfire in under a second, faster than any driver can react.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

And small dogs and little wheeled things are allowed in the park, and they always will be.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

This is not a training failure.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

More training will not fix it.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

It's biology doing what millions of years of evolution designed it to do in an environment that will never stop asking it to do the opposite.

Member of the Public - Laura Spielman

This is why accidents will not stop.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you very much.