Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Schulman questions Conservancy on carriage-related costs

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 3:59:51 · 2 min 2 sec

Schulman questions the Conservancy on costs related to horse carriage wear and tear (~$500,000 for Cherry Hill asphalt), sanitation (none spent on horse waste), and whether banning carriages would affect visitor numbers (no).

Lynn C. Schulman

I have a couple of questions for the Conservancy.

Lynn C. Schulman

How much money annually does the Conservancy spend on repairs and maintenance directly related to wear and tear caused

Lynn C. Schulman

by horse carriages.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

Hi, thanks for the question.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

Roger Mosier, Chief of Park Operations for the Conservancy.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

There's not an annual figure.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

It really depends on the projects that we might pursue from time to time.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

We find that the surfaces that the horses walk on are extremely deteriorated.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

For example, Cherry Hill has a loop around the fountain there, and we need to replace that asphalt due to horse damage, and that project is probably $500,000.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Lynn C. Schulman

How much money does the Conservancy spend on sanitation related to horse waste?

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

We don't spend money on that.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

We don't attempt to clean up after the horses.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

We do have a little bit of inefficiency related to working around the horses on our own trash removal, but we don't clean up after the horses.

Lynn C. Schulman

Has the Conservancy seen an increase in the number of people visiting the park?

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

Yes.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

Thank you for the question.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

You know, it's very hard to know.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

Our general estimate is that we get 42 million visitors a year.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

I think we saw a dramatic increase in general after cars were banned from the park in 2019.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

And also during the pandemic, many people came to the park because it was the only place to go.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

And I think they have continued those patterns since that time.

Member of the Public - David Saltonstall

So we really have seen a dramatic increase in the last five or six years.

Lynn C. Schulman

Do you think the banning of horse carriages would affect the number of visitors?

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

I do not.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

I know that there are a certain percentage of tourists who do avail themselves of horse carriages, but I don't think those 42 million people are coming to the park just to take a horse carriage ride.

Lynn C. Schulman

All right.

Lynn C. Schulman

Those are my questions.

Lynn C. Schulman

I'm going to ask Councilmember Gennaro.

Lynn C. Schulman

He has some questions for you.