Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Menin questions agencies on fatal incident and worker protections

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 0:45:52 · 2 min 30 sec

Speaker Menin questions both agencies about the fatal June incident where the driver left the horse unattended, asks about worker protection provisions, and how many workers would be affected. Ortiz confirms 208 licensed drivers, ~170 active.

Julie Menin

Okay, thank you so much, Chair.

Julie Menin

So a number of questions.

Julie Menin

Thank you for your testimony today.

Julie Menin

So questions for DCWP.

Julie Menin

During the fatal incident involving Romange in June, the driver reportedly left the horse and carriage unattended to take a photograph of the family members, after which the horse became startled and bolted.

Julie Menin

What is the agency's, both agencies'position on this incident?

Corinne Schiff

The administrative code is very clear that drivers may not leave the horse unattended.

Corinne Schiff

The health department, as I noted in my testimony, provides the training course for aspiring carriage horse drivers, and we do include

Corinne Schiff

that key safety provision in that training.

Corinne Schiff

The enforcement of that action is under review at the health department right now.

Carlos Ortiz

I would also add, Speaker, please, to echo, I believe, testimony that's been submitted by the Mayor's Office of Animal Welfare.

Carlos Ortiz

Is that I think the incident overall, it goes back to the inherent challenges that exist when horses are working in these busy urban environments, and ultimately why I think the administration is supportive of a long-term solution to the horse-drawn carriage

Carlos Ortiz

industry, keeping in mind, of course, outcomes and pathways that are sustainable for the workers in this industry as well, which is of critical importance for the Department of Consumer Worker Protection as well.

Carlos Ortiz

Thank you.

Julie Menin

Okay.

Julie Menin

You mentioned in your testimony, the health department testimony, about worker protections in the bill, which is something I am focused on as well.

Julie Menin

What are the specific worker protections, and I guess why is that testimony coming not from DCWP?

Carlos Ortiz

Thank you, Speaker.

Carlos Ortiz

I think for the, just for an operational side, I just have one testimony to represent the administration's position.

Carlos Ortiz

Of course, I'm here to comment on the worker touchpoint as well.

Carlos Ortiz

You know, certainly I think to provide some concrete feedback, workforce development is not necessarily something that DCBP engages in now.

Carlos Ortiz

There are many other agencies that do that work.

Carlos Ortiz

Notwithstanding, we would like to be actively involved in this conversation as well as it relates to outcomes for the workers and ensuring that we have sustainable pathways forward for them.

Julie Menin

Is there specific language that the administration is recommending?

Carlos Ortiz

I don't have language available at this time, but I think as we move through the legislative process, we will be providing language.