Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Mindy Pless (horsewoman) testifies opposing ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 4:17:11 · 2 min 22 sec

Mindy Pless, a native New Yorker and horsewoman now living on a Virginia farm, testifies about her childhood carriage ride inspiring her career, argues the park's carriage paths were designed for horses, and warns PETA's agenda extends to all equine disciplines.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I will.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

My name is Mindy Pless, a native New Yorker, but I now live on a farm in Virginia.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

If I may share a success story of the carriages.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I'm not one of the carriage drivers.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

My career is in animal health, but I've been a lifelong horsewoman.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I was a horse-crazy kid.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

My parents didn't own horses, but my grandmother indulged me.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

She was a buyer at one of the department stores in Manhattan.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

She said, you need to come to Central Park with me.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I need to show you something that you'll never believe.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

We went on a carriage ride.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

And I was besotted.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I just loved it.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

It was fantastic.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I read about the history of the park and the carriages and the original designers of the park.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

It was meant for three specific carriage paths, horse trails, and pedestrians.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

When I'm looking at that recent video, although horrific that that boy died and I let him rest in peace, I'm looking at that video and I'm going, what the heck happened to the carriage paths?

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

You have every mode of transportation on there.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

As a horsewoman, I would never allow my child, because she's inherited my love for horses, be on a horse with other modes of transportation.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

You have bikes, you have e-bikes, you have rollerbladers, you have kids, you have everything.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

Those paths were made specifically for the carriage horses.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

And I'm sorry, but when I hear that word antiquity, I'm still riding, and I'm still riding horses.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

Just because it's not the 1800s and we don't use horses for transportation doesn't mean people like me that have a passion for riding and being on a horse,

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

are you going to come after me next, seizing my horses, because you say, oh, get off, you're hurting that horse.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

This is my fear with PETA involved.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

You know their agenda is to end any equine discipline.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

I am here to tell you, no, you cannot allow the precedent to be set.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

And I ask you to reconsider this and listen to the carriage drivers and come up with solutions and let the horses have those carriage paths back.

Member of the Public - Mindy Pless

Thank you for your attention.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Roger Mosier

You want to go?