Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Hudson questions DCAS on Urban Fellows retention rates

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 0:26:30 · 3 min 20 sec

Hudson asks about the drop from 77% to 38% retention in the Urban Fellows Program; Otar explains the program year and factors like vacancies and candidate interest.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you so much, Chair, and hello, Deputy Commissioner.

Crystal Hudson

One question I had from your testimony was you said we continue to see a growing number of fellows remaining in city government.

Crystal Hudson

This was specifically about the Urban Fellows Program.

Crystal Hudson

With 77% staying on last year and 38% staying on this year, which years...

Crystal Hudson

Can those numbers be attributed to specifically calendar years, fiscal years?

Katie Ann Otar

So that'll be for the program year.

Katie Ann Otar

So our Urban Fellow program year usually starts from the, let's say this year we have a new group that starts from 2026, so they'll go into 2027.

Katie Ann Otar

So for the 38%, it was from 2025 to 2026.

Katie Ann Otar

And then for the 78%, it was from 2024 into 2025.

Katie Ann Otar

So they run from September to June.

Crystal Hudson

September to August.

Katie Ann Otar

We have some people that may stay on until August, yes.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, I'm just trying to figure out why there was such a drop, and if the year that you're referring to the 38% is completed, or if this is a partial number.

Katie Ann Otar

So it's completed.

Katie Ann Otar

There are several factors that ties into whether or not individuals are able to stay on.

Katie Ann Otar

As we mentioned, it's a nine-month program.

Katie Ann Otar

And so we do a couple of things in order to keep folks that are engaged and interested in city government.

Katie Ann Otar

We also know that individuals that participate in the program, they may relocate from a different city or state to participate.

Katie Ann Otar

And so it also depends on the opportunities that are available to them.

Katie Ann Otar

So we know that for the 78%, which was for the previous program.

Crystal Hudson

You said 24 is 25.

Crystal Hudson

And sorry, I didn't catch the nine-month piece.

Crystal Hudson

Yes, both are completed.

Crystal Hudson

But the 77% you said is from 24 into 25?

Katie Ann Otar

Yes.

Crystal Hudson

Okay.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, sorry.

Crystal Hudson

I stopped you in the middle.

Katie Ann Otar

Yes, and so it really depends on the vacancies and the positions that are available and the interest of the candidates.

Katie Ann Otar

We do a lot of focus on making sure people are aware of the civil service process, aware and taking civil service exams.

Katie Ann Otar

There may be opportunities that are directly related to the positions that they are interned, they're doing the fellowship with.

Katie Ann Otar

So they're able to go into that full-time positions at the agencies.

Katie Ann Otar

For the last program year that ends up where we're at 38%, we know that there are still individuals that are interested and engaged.

Katie Ann Otar

They're currently going through the interview process.

Katie Ann Otar

They may be considering or taking an exam and waiting on a list to be hired.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, so then based on that, I would say it's safe to assume that perhaps more people from the last year could potentially be hired.

Katie Ann Otar

Yes.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, so the 77% is counting people from the 24-25 year who could have still been hired in 2026.

Crystal Hudson

And so that could be attributable to the lower number with the 38%.

Crystal Hudson

It just seems like a big drop.

Crystal Hudson

So I'm just trying to figure out.

Crystal Hudson

Definitely.

Crystal Hudson

77% seems like a great number.

Crystal Hudson

And a lot of people that moved on into, you know, civil servant work and 38%, not so much.

Crystal Hudson

But if people are still going through the process and.

Katie Ann Otar

People are still going through the process.

Crystal Hudson

Okay.