Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Dinowitz asks DOE about rigor of Seal projects

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 0:49:34 · 1 min 51 sec

Dinowitz asks about the content, depth, and rigor of Seal projects. Ryle says the handbook aligns every project to commencement-level standards and the accreditation rubric ensures consistent rigor.

Eric Dinowitz

Okay.

Eric Dinowitz

I want to stay with that and talk about

Eric Dinowitz

The projects, first of all, when we met with principals and teachers, they were very pleased with the way that the office runs and that you have these sample – it's not just you guys –

Eric Dinowitz

that you have these sample projects, things that are vetted and accredited.

Eric Dinowitz

I– Ms.

Eric Dinowitz

Fine, in your testimony, you had said–

Eric Dinowitz

that

Eric Dinowitz

These pathways are varied, and learning demonstrated by SEAL recipients may not be uniform in content, depth, or alignment with a particular college course.

Eric Dinowitz

And that touches on some of the concerns we have about the portrait.

Eric Dinowitz

Not its alignment to a specific course, but its content, depth, and alignment.

Eric Dinowitz

And alignment with a curriculum.

Eric Dinowitz

Can you speak to the content and depth, and I'll use the word rigor as well, of these projects?

Eric Dinowitz

Are they all of the same rigor?

Jenna Ryle

So the handbook lays out the commencement level standards that every project is supposed to align to.

Jenna Ryle

And then the accreditation process and the rubric that goes for each project demonstrates how that project would align to those commencement level standards.

Jenna Ryle

And so I think, you know, connecting it back to what you were talking about in terms of a portrait of a graduate, that maybe the pathway to the standpoint.

Jenna Ryle

can vary, but the actual demonstration and application of standards, knowledge, and attributes is going to be the same level based on that project.

Jenna Ryle

But those projects might look slightly different given the context of a school.