Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Dinowitz asks DOE whether civic opportunities vary by poverty

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 0:47:49 · 1 min 45 sec

Dinowitz asks whether DOE tracks which high schools offer civic participation opportunities and whether offerings differ by poverty level. Ryle says DOE does not have that data right now.

Eric Dinowitz

To earn the seal, students need at least two points in civic participation, which come from civics projects, service learning, civic engagement, electives, extracurriculars, and work-based learning.

Eric Dinowitz

Does the DOE track which high school offers the individual opportunities?

Eric Dinowitz

And do those offerings differ by the school's poverty level?

Jenna Ryle

I don't believe we have the data right now to know whether the offerings for the specific opportunities differ by the school makeup.

Jenna Ryle

But I think Chris can speak to the way that we are tracking what are the projects that each school is offering because either they are taking from

Jenna Ryle

a vetted list of accredited projects or they are submitting a project for accreditation as part of their process for becoming a high school that offers the sealed civic readiness.

Jenna Ryle

Yeah, so another part of our handbook for the seal for New York City public schools is our academic integrity procedure section.

Jenna Ryle

And so that outlines the sort of accreditation policies that I'll be talking about, but to what Delia was just mentioning.

Jenna Ryle

So we work with internal DOE offices and external organizations to accredit projects or electives for citywide use.

Jenna Ryle

And those are available for any school to add to their school's programming.

Jenna Ryle

But schools also can develop 2A civics projects or 2C civics electives that they submit instructional materials to us for review for.

Jenna Ryle

And we match those against the specifications in the handbook to accredit them or not, or the 2F capstone, which is more of a sort of planning document.