Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Remarks

Council Member Bottcher Explains Vote on General Orders

New York City Council · Apr 24, 2025 · starts 0:53:41 · 2 min 3 sec

Council Member Eric Bottcher explains his vote, drawing parallels between past struggles for gay rights and the current fight for trans rights, urging compassion and legal safeguards.

Erik D. Bottcher

Permission to explain my vote.

Amanda C. Farías

Permission granted.

Erik D. Bottcher

Look, it wasn't that long ago that gays and lesbians were widely to considered to be predators who were trying to recruit kids.

Erik D. Bottcher

And we've made a tremendous amount of progress on gay and lesbian rights.

Erik D. Bottcher

When I was I was born a year before homosexuality was decriminalized in New York State.

Erik D. Bottcher

We've come a long way.

Erik D. Bottcher

But one of the reasons we've been able to come a long way is because people know people got to know us as we came out.

Erik D. Bottcher

People knew us in their lives as their relative, as their coworker.

Erik D. Bottcher

And they knew that those that wasn't true, that we weren't those terrible things that were being depicted.

Erik D. Bottcher

The challenge with trans rights is that they're so much fewer in number that so few people know trans people in their lives.

Erik D. Bottcher

If they did, they would know that they were just they're just people trying to live their lives, trying to take care of themselves and their families.

Erik D. Bottcher

They're not trying to go out trying to recruit other people.

Erik D. Bottcher

It's it's a vicious, vicious stereotype.

Erik D. Bottcher

And look, folks don't choose to be trans no more than folks choose to be gay.

Erik D. Bottcher

My life would have been a lot easier.

Erik D. Bottcher

I'd probably be working in my father's fly fishing shop.

Erik D. Bottcher

I'd probably be like drinking a Miller Light on a porch somewhere right now.

Erik D. Bottcher

But no, I didn't have a choice.

Erik D. Bottcher

I am who I am.

Erik D. Bottcher

They are who they are.

Erik D. Bottcher

Let's continue to pass legislation that safeguards their rights.

Erik D. Bottcher

It's not complicated.

Erik D. Bottcher

I'm proud that's that's what we're doing in the body today.

Council Staff

Your vote, council member.

Council Staff

Your vote?

Erik D. Bottcher

Aye, and all.

Council Staff

Thank you.