Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

New York City Council

Stated Meeting

Apr 24, 2025 · 1:30 PM · 1 hr 34 min
Stated Meeting Vote Land Use

Summary

  • The Council passed a comprehensive legislative package aimed at protecting and expanding rights for transgender, gender nonconforming, and nonbinary New Yorkers, which sparked intense debate among members.
  • Legislation was approved to mitigate helicopter noise pollution by restricting non-essential flights at city heliports that do not meet strict FAA noise standards.
  • The Council voted on various land use, finance, and environmental measures, including the Brownsville NCP affordable housing project and stormwater management plans.

Meeting chapters

Read summaries and jump into the video at the segment start.

0:00:46
1 min 2 sec
Procedure

Call to Order and Roll Call

Council staff calls the meeting to order, requests quiet on the floor, and asks council members to take their seats. Majority Leader Amanda Farías welcomes the public and outlines the rules of conduct for the meeting.

Procedure
0:01:48
5 min 8 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call

Council staff conducts the roll call of members present for the stated meeting, noting the presence of various council members and recognizing State Assembly Member Kalman Yeger in attendance.

ROLL CALL
0:06:56
3 min 20 sec
INVOCATION

Invocation by Reverend Patrick J. Keating

Reverend Patrick J. Keating, Deputy CEO of Catholic Charities Brooklyn and Queens, delivers the invocation.

INVOCATION
0:10:15
1 min 33 sec
Remarks

Motion to Spread Invocation on the Record and Tribute to Pope Francis

Council Member Justin Brannan thanks Reverend Keating for the invocation and pays tribute to the legacy of Pope Francis, highlighting his advocacy for the poor and marginalized. Brannan moves to spread the invocation in full upon the record.

Remarks
0:11:49
32 sec
Procedure

Adoption of Minutes and Communications

Council Member Susan Zhuang moves to adopt the minutes of the previous meeting. The clerk notes that there are no messages from the mayor and reads a communication regarding the election of Simcha Felder to the 44th District.

Procedure
0:12:20
4 min 7 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on Land Use Call-ups

The clerk conducts a roll call vote on the day's land use call-ups, with council members casting their votes individually.

ROLL CALL
0:16:27
9 sec
VOTE OUTCOME

Vote Outcome on Land Use Call-ups

The clerk announces that the land use call-ups are adopted by a vote of 46 in the affirmative and one in the negative.

VOTE OUTCOME
0:16:36
1 min
Remarks

Speaker Adams Pays Tribute to Exenia Met

Speaker Adrienne Adams begins her communications by acknowledging the tragic death of Exenia Met, a beloved Harlem grandmother who was killed by a stray bullet while trying to stop neighborhood violence.

Remarks
0:17:36
2 min 53 sec
Remarks

Speaker Adams Condemns Trump Administration Deportation and Mayor's ICE Policy

Speaker Adams addresses the deportation of Bronx teenager Maruel Gutierrez by the Trump administration. She criticizes Mayor Eric Adams for his silence on the matter and warns against allowing ICE operations on Rikers Island.

Remarks
0:20:29
1 min 20 sec
Remarks

Speaker Adams Recognizes Holidays and Heritage Days

Speaker Adams reflects on the significance of Passover, Easter, Earth Day, Holocaust Remembrance Day, and the upcoming Denim Day to support survivors of sexual violence.

Remarks
0:21:49
51 sec
CEREMONY

Speaker Adams Welcomes JCCA's Arches and Wishes Happy Birthdays

Speaker Adams welcomes young adults from JCCA's Arches program to the chambers and wishes happy birthdays to Council Members Mercedes Narcisse and Chris Marte.

CEREMONY
0:22:40
1 min 20 sec
Remarks

Speaker Adams Outlines Land Use and Finance Agenda Items

Speaker Adams outlines the stated agenda, starting with the Brownsville NCP affordable housing project and several finance items, including a bill regarding the Independent Budget Office's executive budget report.

Remarks
0:24:00
1 min 14 sec
Remarks

Speaker Adams Outlines Home Rule and General Legislation Agenda Items

Speaker Adams details home rule item SLR1 regarding Flushing Meadows Corona Park, a resolution on industrial laundry contracts, and a charter amendment regarding former public servants.

Remarks
0:25:14
1 min 22 sec
Remarks

Speaker Adams Outlines Deed Theft and Community Hiring Legislation

Speaker Adams highlights a package of bills to combat deed theft and predatory real estate practices, as well as legislation requiring reporting on community hiring programs by local development corporations.

Remarks
0:26:36
3 min
Remarks

Speaker Adams Outlines Stormwater and Helicopter Noise Legislation

Speaker Adams discusses legislation to increase stormwater system capacity and a package of bills and resolutions aimed at regulating non-essential helicopter flights to mitigate noise pollution.

Remarks
0:29:36
3 min 18 sec
Remarks

Speaker Adams Outlines Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Protection Legislation

Speaker Adams introduces a package of bills and resolutions designed to protect and support transgender, gender nonconforming, and nonbinary New Yorkers against federal rollbacks.

Remarks
0:32:54
1 min 34 sec
Remarks

Council Member Nurse Discusses Brownsville NCP Housing Project

Council Member Sandy Nurse speaks in support of the Brownsville NCP project, which will bring 75 units of deeply affordable housing to Community Board 16, highlighting the inclusion of three-bedroom units.

Remarks
0:34:27
1 min 57 sec
Remarks

Council Member Cabán Urges Support for Transgender Rights Legislation

Council Member Tiffany Cabán urges colleagues to pass the transgender rights package, emphasizing that New York City must actively lead in protecting the survival and rights of trans residents.

Remarks
0:36:24
2 min 13 sec
Remarks

Council Member Avilés Discusses Community Hiring and EDC Accountability Bills

Council Member Alexa Avilés advocates for her bills, Intros 860 and 861, which aim to increase transparency and accountability regarding community hiring and benefits in EDC-led economic development projects.

Remarks
0:38:38
2 min 3 sec
Remarks

Council Member Gennaro Discusses Stormwater Management Legislation

Council Member Jim Gennaro discusses Intro 115A, which requires the DEP to develop a plan to increase stormwater sewer capacity to combat the increasing frequency of severe flooding events.

Remarks
0:40:41
2 min 1 sec
Remarks

Council Member Hanif Discusses the Affirm Act for Gender-Affirming Care

Council Member Shahana Hanif speaks in support of Intro 1201, the Affirm Act, which establishes safe harbor protections for individuals accessing gender-affirming care in New York City.

Remarks
0:42:42
1 min 34 sec
Remarks

Council Member Vernikov Opposes Transgender Rights Legislation

Council Member Inna Vernikov voices strong opposition to the transgender rights legislative package, arguing that it infringes on parental rights and compromises fairness in women's sports.

Remarks
0:44:16
1 min 44 sec
Remarks

Council Member Mealy Discusses Affordability in Brownsville NCP

Council Member Darlene Mealy expresses concerns regarding the modified affordability levels of the Brownsville NCP project, arguing that city-owned land should remain 100% affordable to the lowest income brackets.

Remarks
0:46:00
1 min 1 sec
Remarks

Council Member Hudson Discusses Gender Option Legislation

Council Member Crystal Hudson speaks in support of Intro 246, which requires city agencies to include an 'X' gender option on demographic forms to ensure inclusivity.

Remarks
0:47:01
2 min 3 sec
Remarks

Majority Leader Farías Discusses Helicopter Noise Mitigation Legislation

Majority Leader Amanda Farías advocates for Intro 26A, which prohibits non-essential helicopter flights from operating out of city-owned heliports unless they meet strict FAA noise standards.

Remarks
0:49:04
1 min 19 sec
Procedure

Reports of Standing Committees and General Orders Calendar

Council staff reads the reports of various standing committees, including Economic Development, Environmental Protection, Finance, Governmental Operations, and Women and Gender Equity, coupling the items on the general orders calendar.

Procedure
0:50:23
56 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on General Orders

The clerk begins the roll call vote on the coupled general orders calendar, with Council Members Marte and Vernikov casting their initial votes.

ROLL CALL
0:51:18
1 min 8 sec
Remarks

Council Member Avilés Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Alexa Avilés explains her vote, thanking advocates who shaped the community hiring bills and expressing proud solidarity with the transgender and gender nonconforming community.

Remarks
0:52:26
1 min 15 sec
Remarks

Council Member Ayala Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Diana Ayala explains her vote, sharing her perspective as a parent of public school students to demystify and defend inclusive school curriculums.

Remarks
0:53:41
2 min 3 sec
Remarks

Council Member Bottcher Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Eric Bottcher explains his vote, drawing parallels between past struggles for gay rights and the current fight for trans rights, urging compassion and legal safeguards.

Remarks
0:55:44
19 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on General Orders Continued

The roll call vote on the general orders calendar continues with Council Members Brannan, Brewer, and Brooks-Powers casting their votes.

ROLL CALL
0:56:03
1 min 43 sec
Remarks

Council Member Cabán Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Tiffany Cabán explains her vote, strongly defending access to gender-affirming healthcare as life-saving medical care supported by major medical associations.

Remarks
0:57:45
1 min 32 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on General Orders Continued

The roll call vote continues with Council Members Carr, Dinowitz, Felder, Feliz, Gennaro, Gutiérrez, Hanif, and Holden casting their votes.

ROLL CALL
0:59:17
1 min 11 sec
Remarks

Council Member Hudson Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Crystal Hudson explains her vote, sharing a personal story about a dedicated black trans woman on her staff to emphasize the human dignity of trans New Yorkers.

Remarks
1:00:28
51 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on General Orders Continued

The roll call vote continues with Council Members Joseph, Lee, and Marmorato casting their votes on the general orders calendar.

ROLL CALL
1:01:19
1 min 45 sec
Remarks

Council Members Mealy, Menin, Nurse, and Ossé Explain Votes

Council Members Mealy, Menin, Nurse, and Ossé explain their votes. Nurse clarifies the affordability of the Brownsville NCP project, while Ossé speaks in defense of the trans community.

Remarks
1:03:04
1 min 47 sec
Remarks

Council Member Paladino Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Vickie Paladino explains her vote, calling for mutual respect and a middle ground while voting 'no' on the transgender rights package.

Remarks
1:04:51
1 min 21 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on General Orders Continued

The roll call vote continues with Council Members Powers, Restler, Riley, Rivera, Salaam, and Salamanca casting their votes.

ROLL CALL
1:06:12
55 sec
Remarks

Council Member Sanchez Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Pierina Sanchez explains her vote, congratulating colleagues on the Affirm Act and aligning herself with remarks supporting trans New Yorkers.

Remarks
1:07:07
45 sec
ROLL CALL

Roll Call Vote on General Orders Continued

The roll call vote continues with Council Members Schulman, Stevens, and Ung casting their votes on the general orders calendar.

ROLL CALL
1:07:52
1 min 23 sec
Remarks

Council Member Williams Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Nantasha Williams explains her vote, highlighting the importance of the trans rights package and her bill to combat deed fraud to protect homeowners.

Remarks
1:09:15
1 min 41 sec
Remarks

Council Member Zhuang Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Susan Zhuang explains her vote, emphasizing that council members are elected to represent and protect their communities rather than engage in divisive rhetoric.

Remarks
1:10:55
1 min 23 sec
Remarks

Council Member Ariola Explains Vote on General Orders

Council Member Joann Ariola explains her vote, criticizing personal attacks made during the session and casting her votes on the general orders calendar.

Remarks
1:12:18
4 min 42 sec
VOTE OUTCOME

Vote Outcome on General Orders Calendar

The clerk announces the final vote tallies, confirming the adoption of all items on the general orders calendar, including SLR1, Intro 26A, and the transgender rights package.

VOTE OUTCOME
1:17:00
14 sec
Procedure

Introduction and Reading of Bills

The clerk notes that all introduced bills have been referred to committees as indicated on the agenda, and the council transitions to the discussion of resolutions.

Procedure
1:17:14
1 min 31 sec
Remarks

Council Member Gennaro Discusses Resolution 8: Lead Service Line Replacement Funding

Council Member Jim Gennaro discusses Resolution 8, calling on state agencies to fairly allocate federal infrastructure funds to New York City for lead service line replacement.

Remarks
1:18:44
1 min 5 sec
Remarks

Council Member Brewer Discusses Helicopter Noise Resolutions

Council Member Gail Brewer discusses Resolutions 233A and 226A, which call on federal and state authorities to ban or restrict non-essential helicopter flights over the city.

Remarks
1:19:49
53 sec
Remarks

Council Member Nurse Discusses Resolution 327: Retroactive Property Tax Exemptions

Council Member Sandy Nurse discusses Resolution 327, calling on the state to pass legislation allowing eligible property owners to receive retroactive property tax exemptions.

Remarks
1:20:42
1 min 34 sec
Remarks

Council Member Krishnan Discusses Resolution 852: Protecting Social Security

Council Member Shekar Krishnan discusses Resolution 852, calling on the federal government to protect Social Security from proposed cuts and defend benefits for seniors.

Remarks
1:22:16
27 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 8: Lead Service Line Replacement Funding

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 8, urging fair allocation of federal funds for lead service line replacement.

VOICE VOTE
1:22:43
19 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 85A: Helicopter Noise Tax

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 85A, calling for a noise tax on non-essential helicopter and seaplane flights.

VOICE VOTE
1:23:02
18 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 144A: Water Infrastructure Funding

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 144A, calling for the removal of funding caps on water infrastructure upgrades.

VOICE VOTE
1:23:20
20 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 226A: Restricting Heliport Operations

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 226A, calling for a prohibition on certain non-essential flight operations at municipal heliports.

VOICE VOTE
1:23:40
17 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 233A: Banning Non-Essential Helicopter Flights

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 233A, calling on the FAA to ban non-essential helicopter travel over New York City.

VOICE VOTE
1:23:57
19 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 327: Retroactive Property Tax Exemptions

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 327, calling for state legislation to authorize retroactive property tax exemptions.

VOICE VOTE
1:24:16
22 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 598: Industrial Laundry Contracts

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 598, calling on healthcare institutions to contract with laundry companies that respect workers' rights.

VOICE VOTE
1:24:38
21 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 771: Personal Health Information Protections

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 771, calling on the governor to sign legislation extending protections over personal health information.

VOICE VOTE
1:24:59
25 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 774: Transgender Standards of Care in Hospitals

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 774, calling for regulations requiring hospitals to adhere to WPATH standards of care.

VOICE VOTE
1:25:24
23 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 781: Restricting Out-of-State Prescription Data Access

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 781, calling for a prohibition on out-of-state access to prescription monitoring data for certain medications.

VOICE VOTE
1:25:47
34 sec
VOICE VOTE

Voice Vote on Resolution 793: Sensitive Health Information Protections

The Council conducts a voice vote and adopts Resolution 793, calling for additional protections for sensitive health information related to abortion or gender-affirming care.

VOICE VOTE
1:26:21
1 min 52 sec
Remarks

Council Member Brewer Pays Tribute to Barry Benepe

During general discussion, Council Member Gail Brewer pays tribute to Barry Benepe, the co-founder of the Greenmarket, who passed away at age 96, highlighting his contributions to the city.

Remarks
1:28:13
1 min 26 sec
Remarks

Council Member Holden Introduces Fire Hydrant and Rodeo Animal Protection Bills

Council Member Robert Holden introduces legislation to strengthen enforcement against fire hydrant obstruction and to ban inhumane animal practices in rodeos.

Remarks
1:29:39
1 min 22 sec
Remarks

Council Member Sanchez Introduces Housing Connect Improvement Bills

Council Member Pierina Sanchez introduces a package of three bills aimed at improving the Housing Connect application system, reducing wait times, and providing assistance to applicants.

Remarks
1:31:01
1 min 30 sec
Remarks

Council Member Lee Introduces Juvenile Detention Staff Training Bill

Council Member Linda Lee introduces Intro 1259, which requires direct service staff in juvenile detention facilities to receive training in behavioral support and de-escalation strategies.

Remarks
1:32:32
1 min 36 sec
Remarks

Council Member Krishnan Discusses Resolution to Protect Social Security

Council Member Shekar Krishnan reiterates the importance of protecting Social Security and urges colleagues to support his resolution calling on the federal government to prevent cuts.

Remarks
1:34:08
31 sec
Remarks

Council Member Mealy Welcomes Simcha Felder and Kalman Yeger

Council Member Darlene Mealy welcomes newly elected Council Member Simcha Felder back to the Council and congratulates Kalman Yeger on his transition to the State Assembly.

Remarks
1:34:39
17 sec
Procedure

Adjournment

Speaker Adrienne Adams formally adjourns the stated meeting of April 24, 2025.

Procedure