Subcommittee called to order and housekeeping
Council staff opens the meeting of the Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises, reminds attendees to silence devices and not approach the dais.
NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.
Created by Uzair Qadir
Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings
New York City Council
Zoning, Monitor Point, Brooklyn (C 260105 ZMK)
Read summaries and jump into the video at the segment start.
Council staff opens the meeting of the Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises, reminds attendees to silence devices and not approach the dais.
Chair Farah Louis calls the meeting to order, introduces fellow council members, and announces the subcommittee will vote on three proposals covering LU 72 through 77.
Chair Louis describes the first development site at 801 11th Avenue, seeking a mixed-use residential building with approximately 477 apartments, 125 permanently affordable, and a zoning map amendment from M2-3 to C4-7.
Chair Louis explains the second site at 629 West 54th Street with approximately 617 apartments, 162 affordable, and the proposed transfer of floor area from Hudson River Park piers in exchange for $229.7 million to the Hudson River Park Trust.
Chair Louis outlines the zoning map amendments, text amendments for mandatory inclusionary housing, special permits for floor area transfer, and recommended modifications including removal of the street wall waiver and reducing building height from 550 to 520 feet.
Brewer explains the two separately owned buildings, the FAR transfer from Hudson River Park Trust generating at least $29 million, and extensive community board engagement with CB4.
Brewer describes CB4's sophisticated review, their negative declaration unless milestones were met, and the community's desire for greater height reduction than the 30 feet achieved.
Brewer highlights the city park across the street needing $6 million bathroom and $6 million playground renovations, but the developer only committed $200,000 over several years.
Brewer details the fight for additional workforce housing beyond MIH requirements, settling for 1.25% additional permanent affordable units (12-13 units) after extensive negotiation, and the importance of rent stabilization.
Brewer discusses the developer's dislike of the 485X tax abatement, uncertainty about whether the project will be built, and the existing active union jobs on the site.
Brewer expresses frustration with HPD's reluctance to subsidize affordable housing in high-income Manhattan neighborhoods, calls on 32BJ to advocate for more workforce housing, and demands rent stabilization for the negotiated units.
Chair Louis introduces LU 67, 68, 69, and 71 for the Monitor Point project in Council Member Restler's district, describing the mixed-use development with a museum, market-rate building, and affordable housing building on MTA-controlled land.
Louis explains the site's uniqueness: publicly owned MTA land in an area rezoned before MIH requirements, offering a rare chance to build affordable housing for low-income New Yorkers alongside waterfront green space.
Louis announces modifications increasing affordable units from 460 to 662, including converting commercial space to residential, reallocating museum space, extending the development site, and adding height to the East Building.
Louis describes the zoning map amendment, text amendment for MIH, special permit for large-scale development with bulk modifications, and city map change to remove park designation, noting LU 70 was withdrawn.
Louis explains changes to the special permit drawings to increase affordable apartments, modifications to the waterfront publicly accessible area waiver, and notes Council Member Restler's support.
Restler recounts the five-year negotiation, from initial opposition to reaching a final agreement, with affordable housing increased from 25% to 50% of units, totaling 662 affordable apartments.
Restler specifies that 50% of affordable units are deeply affordable, 161 units for seniors, and 110 units of supportive housing for formerly homeless individuals with on-site services.
Restler describes expanded public green space, a 40-foot waterfront esplanade, $300,000 annual contribution to Bushwick Inlet Park, MTA relocation from Box Street Park, and flood protection measures.
Restler highlights a $60 million elevator project at Nassau Avenue G station, 2,700 square feet of community facility space for local nonprofits, and union construction and building service jobs.
Restler thanks Speaker Menon, Chair Lewis, Land Use Chair Riley, and the Council Land Use Team for their support through the difficult negotiation.
Restler expresses gratitude to the MTA, Gotham Organization developers, the Mumdani administration, and community advocates including Save the Inlet and Churches United for Fair Housing.
Restler praises his district staff — Hannah, Eliza, and Molly — for their exceptional work on the Monitor Point project.
Louis asks for questions or remarks, receives none, and calls for a roll call vote on all LU items and a motion to file LU 70.
All nine subcommittee members vote aye on all items, with several offering congratulations to Council Members Brewer and Restler.
Council staff announces the vote of nine affirmative, zero opposing, zero abstentions; all items are approved and referred to the full Land Use Committee. Chair Louis adjourns the meeting.